The True White House : a Controversy

The True White House : a Controversy

The construction of the White House in Washington was inspired by a French chateau. The similitude is extraordinary.

The White House, Washington and the Chateau of Rastignac, France

Thomas Jefferson (1743-1826), third President of the United States of America, main writer of the Declaration of Independence, was a talented architect and archeologist. He was Minister to France from 1785 to 1789 where he had for friend the famous architect Charles-Louis Clérisseau. When Jefferson visited Bordeaux in 1789 and namely the “Ecole Spéciale d’Architecture”, he saw a copy of a drawing for a chateau due to be built in 1780 near La Bachellerie in Dordogne. The owner, Marquis de Chapt de Rastignac, had to leave France to escape the guillotine. Some historians say that Jefferson was inspired by the Chateau of Rastignac for the construction of the White House in Washington, which began in 1792. The Chateau of Rastignac was only built from 1812 to 1817 by Mathurin Salat, suffered a lot during WWII, was listed only in 1946, restored in 1952 and recently bought by a Dutch family. It is now a private estate.

The similitude is really extraordinary. Already in 1962, a guide to the White House noted a link on Hoban’s drawing of the South Portico with the Chateau of Rastignac. Hoban however never travelled to France, but it has been made certain that Jefferson shared his discovery with George Washington, Hoban, Monroe and Latrobe.

Another house, “La Maison Carrée d’Arlac”, located near Bordeaux, in Mérignac, resembles the White House very much. It is a Palladian mansion with hemispherical peristyle and columns opening on a salon in rotunda with a cupola. There is a circular gallery for musicians in the salon. Built from 1785 to 1789 this house might have inspired the Chateau of Rastignac as well. The “Hôtel de Salm” (1782-1788), Museum of the Legion of Honor, in Paris can also be compared to the White House.

So, who copied what? The most important is that we can still admire these marvellous monuments.

please check out also my other article: http://quazen.com/arts/art-history/the-white-house-a-highly-coveted-mansion/

93
Liked it
9 Comments
chris73, posted this comment on Apr 30th, 2009

Realy interesting.

PhoenixRox, posted this comment on Jul 19th, 2009

Wow! This is a really interesting article. They do look so similar! LOL.. Hard to tell who copied whom. :) ..Good one Francois!

Ruby Hawk, posted this comment on Sep 7th, 2009

It woud be interesting to know, but as you say we can enjoy without knowing.

Sterling Christianson, posted this comment on Sep 22nd, 2009

I enjoyed this article. It makes one think about inspirations and influences in all aspects of life. There is no doubt France had a definite impact when architectural designers constructed many of our popular monuments and stately manors here in the U.S. We don’t have but 200 plus years of actual national history. France has many, many more centuries ahead of us. Great article Francois.

Francois Hagnere, posted this comment on Nov 25th, 2009

Thank you for you nice comments. Please check out my related article: “The White House: A Highly Coveted Mansion” describing the history, the rooms and furniture of this prestigious house.

PhoenixRox, posted this comment on Dec 7th, 2009

Still as interesting as the 1st time

Likha, posted this comment on Aug 12th, 2010

You should be an investigative journalist Francois. I’m impressed.

neopisiva, posted this comment on May 26th, 2011

I was in Washington some years ago,they are full with european architecture,it`s copies everywhere you go…
But,it`s all well done architecture,of course.
Great share.

1Arjun, posted this comment on Jun 1st, 2011

Very Interesting..

Leave a Response